What Are Our Options?

Discover the pros and cons of four options for the future of our Community Centre.

Where do you start with a project like this? We have a Centre that’s been closed for 19 months, the group that ran the Centre stood down and there hasn't been much by way of keeping the local community informed. The first thing we had to do was establish a new body of like-minded people to drive things forward and this we’ve now done. We’re small in number, but big in determination.

Through both conversations between ourselves and input from residents, we found ourselves with a number of options for the future of the Community Centre. We could do the bare minimum and have the existing Centre repaired and re-opened, we could consider having the existing Centre repaired and refurbished, we could look at demolishing the existing Centre and building a new one on the same site, or we could look at having a new Centre built elsewhere in the village.

The first step was to carry out an analysis of each of these four options, weighing up the strengths and weaknesses of each. Below is a summary of each option, but the full analysis document is available for download at the bottom of this article for anyone that wants to dig deeper.

1. Repair and reopen the existing centre

This would certainly be the quickest and least expensive way to get the Centre back into use. It would involve repairing the subsidence damage, dealing with the damp and mould that’s set in since closure and return the Centre to the minimum standard needed for reopening. However,everyone who has been in the Centre will know it’s very dated, there are other areas that need extensive maintenance, the layout isn’t good or flexible for varying community needs and the building is very inefficient.Reopening sooner would give local groups a place to return to, but the ageing building, dated facilities and energy inefficiency would still need attention and could lead to further extensive closures and greater expense in the future.

2. Repair and refurbish the existing centre

A wider refurbishment alongside repairing the subsidence damage could tackle a number of the existing issues, improve heating and ventilation, make the building more accessible and adapt the layout for the activities people want to run. It would keep the familiar location, access and parking, and could cost less and take less time than a replacement. How much it would cost and how far the building could be improved are still open questions. More detailed surveys on such an old building could also reveal further defects that are currently hidden.

3. Replace the Centre on its current site

Demolishing the existing Centre and rebuilding on the same site could give Kincardine a modern, more accessible, energy-efficient building with greater flexibility and rooms designed around local needs. It would keep the Centre in its familiar location in the heart of the village and avoid the cost of buying another site. However, demolition would remove the possibility of reopening the old building, so before this option could proceed, ground suitability, building approvals and full funding would all need to be confirmed.

4. Build a new centre on a different site

The fourth option considered a new four-acre site with room for a purpose-built centre, parking and outdoor activities. A larger site could also accommodate a wider range of community services. Buying land and providing access and utilities would make this the most expensive option identified in the appraisal. Planning, ground investigations and funding could all extend the time the village spends without a Centre by years and, with the proposed site not being central to the village, it may prove less attractive to less mobile residents. This remains a reserve option if the current site proves unsuitable and the alternative offers benefits that justify the extra cost.

Where we go from here

Based on the analysis carried out, rebuilding a new Centre on the current site is currently the provisional preference with repair and refurbishment in second place. The next step in the appraisal proposes is to cost the rebuild and a comprehensive refurbishment against the same set of community needs. That would show what each could offer, how long Kincardine would be without a centre and what each would cost to build and run.

pdf Kincardine Community Centre Future Options Appraisal.pdf 468Kb

Download the full analysis document detailing the strengths and weaknesses of each of the four options we considered

Our Kincardine

Working together to bring our Community Centre back to the heart of our village.

Useful Links

Have Your Say

The Legal Stuff